It’s For Your Own Good

Before you arrest anybody, ask yourself what your real motives are. Are you doing it to protect society? To take revenge? Or to seek the moral reform of your arrestee?

And before you declare war on anybody, ask yourself whether you are contributing to the protection of society from evil, as you are being told. Or are you responding to your humanitarian instincts to protect your enemy’s victims, in which case the purity of your motive may blind you to the dangers of unexpected consequences.

In either case you may not be aware that you are being duped by those whose real reason is merely to establish, maintain or expand their power, one way or another.

In retrospect, even the best thinkers occasionally lapsed.

In the middle of the nineteenth century the patron saint of our conception of liberty, John Stuart Mill, thought that despotism “was a legitimate mode of dealing with barbarians” provided “the end be their improvement.” In the era of colonialism the concept of the white man’s burden was by no means far-fetched.

Nor is it today.

The title of a book by the English activist Richard Seymour in which he examines in unsparing detail the conduct of well-meaning supporters of foreign interventions by Western powers in recent years has the title The Liberal Defence of Murder.

2 Responses to It’s For Your Own Good

  1. Quousque tandem patientia abutere nostras patentia.

  2. A lot of the motivation behind Quebec’s move to deprive women who wear veils of many public services is to ‘free’ them from male oppression – even if the women themselves consider that the decision to wear the veil was their own.

    Enormous oppression has been visited on people because of their ‘false consciousness’ of what they thought they wanted – but someone else knew what they ‘really’ wanted and made the choice for them, i.e. compelled them to change.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s