A Question for Music-Lovers: Did Beethoven Compose at the Speed at Which He Intended the Work to be Performed?

There is no evidence that anybody has ever asked that question. But that is no reason we should not ask it now. Let us, therefore, consider this excerpt from an invented exchange of letters. (Elements of it, however, are based on real correspondence.)

On July 3, 1812, the eleven-year old girl Emilie M. asked the question (among many others) in an adulatory letter to Beethoven in these terms:

“…I have been practicing your violin sonata in A major. You marked the last movement presto. Did you compose it presto?”

To which he answered three weeks later from Treplitz, a spa in Bohemia:

“My dear good Emilie, my dear friend, forgive me for the delay in answering your letter. I have been plagued by constant illness and I am here for the restoration of my health. Your praise is too immoderate; do not snatch the laurel wreath from Handel, Haydn, Mozart – to them it belongs, to me not yet.

“You ask whether I composed the presto movement in the sonata to which you refer at presto speed. The answer is YES! In my mind I heard it presto, but when I wrote it down I struggled with it at adagio speed, again and again. How I envy Rossini, who apparently writes his adagio arias at presto speed!

“Continue, my dear Emilie. Do not only practice art but penetrate to the very heart of it. This it deserves, for only art and science raise men to the Godhead….”

About these ads

2 Responses to A Question for Music-Lovers: Did Beethoven Compose at the Speed at Which He Intended the Work to be Performed?

  1. Bellissimo.

  2. Of course we see our work of art in a “muse’s dream” or its entirety. The hard part is recreating it so others can share that dream.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s