Tag Archives: surveillance

If I Can Spy on You, We Can Spy on Me

If it can be done, it will be done. No ethical or legal inhibitions will stop me. That is the inexorable logic of technological progress.

Or so it seems.

However, clearly that is not true. Since 1945, no nuclear power has dropped a nuclear bomb – so far.

Having them is what counts.

For a variety of reasons, recent disclosures are likely to force similar restraints on nations – above all on the United States – engaged in surveillance and espionage activities that infringe on the privacy of national leaders.

In case the inexorable logic of technological progress – or the stubbornness of politicians – blocks such restraints, national leaders may be well advised to instruct their technology experts to invent new means to protect their privacy.

The Virtues of Government Secrecy

Bradley Manning and Edward Snowden’s defenders make what seems like an unassailable argument grounded in democracy: In a democracy, the people discipline government officials who act badly by throwing them out of office, but they can do so only if they know what the government does. Hence, government policy and activities cannot be secret. Manning and Snowden, by defying secrecy, are heroes to democracy, as shown by Congress’ efforts to revise NSA powers in light of Snowden’s revelations.

But this “democracy requires transparency” argument is incomplete.

Consider the opposite argument, which we can call “democracy requires secrecy.” People exercise their democratic rights by directing the government to engage in various projects. In many cases, these projects can be effective only if they are secret. People who disclose projects that work best if they are conducted in secret undermine democracy by depriving the people of the most effective tools for governing themselves.

Source: Slate Magazine, August 5